L-R: Arnel Bernas, Noel Pantoja, Mark Sosmena, Joel Macatangay, Joel Eyestone, Fred Magbanua, Elmer Miguel, Onie Avante. This was an impromptu meeting between senior leaders of CBAP and CJOL

PAR is Peace and Reconciliation.

A very significant PAR meeting happened before my eyes yesterday afternoon. But it was not planned by human beings. I believe it was a Divine Appointment.

We were driving from Clark, Pampanga to Manila at around 2:00 PM, informally reflecting on our individual experiences at the recently-concluded 29th National Assembly of the Philippine Council of Evangelical Churches (PCEC). I was travelling with the management team of the Conservative Baptist Association of the Philippines (CBAP). Bishop Noel Pantoja, CBAP General Director, was driving. (Yes, we’re related. He’s my younger brother.) With us were Pastor Joel Macatangay, CBAP Director of Church Planting; Rev. Arnel Bernas, CBAP Director of Church Development; and, Rev. Joel Eyestone, CBAP Director of Theological Education by Extension.

I was curious how these executives of a major evangelical group in the country would translate the new PCEC thrust of community and national transformation into their own areas of responsibilities. So, I challenged them: “Guys, I’d buy you coffee if you would answer my questions on bridging the vision of transformation into actual church policies and programs.”

“You’re on!” they agreed.

We started our discussion.

When Noel saw a Starbucks coffee shop at the Shell of Asia along North Luzon Expressway, we stopped for coffee. All of us ordered our choice of coffee.

I was about to pay the cashier when Mark Sosmena, who was travelling alone, entered the coffee shop. Mark is the President of the Board of CBAP. He offered to pay for all the coffee drinks we ordered.

A few minutes later, Bishop Fred Magbanua entered the coffee shop we were in. Bishop Fred is the senior spiritual leader of Christ Jesus Our Life (CJOL) Church—a national church planting movement advocating for, and practicing, holistic ministry. With him were Rev. Elmer Miguel, Chief Executive Officer of CJOL; and, Rev. Onie Avante, Chief Operating Officer of CJOL.

We had coffee together. The first few minutes were full of jokes and laughter.

Then we were led to reflect together on the meaning of peace, justice, and righteousness within the Body of Christ. We agreed that transformation must start in the Church.
Bishop Magbanua, whom we honor as a patriarch in PCEC, said: “What does peace, justice, and righteousness mean in the relationship between CBAP and CJOL?”

We were all silent for a while. I felt he Spirit of God searching our hearts.

“Let me share what’s in my heart,” Bishop Magbanua continued. “I noticed that you neglected some important segments of our journey together. If you’ll remember, CJOL started as a holistic church-planting movement within the umbrella of CBAP. We envisioned to plant churches that plant churches who, in turn, would respond to the needs of people in all aspects of life—spiritual, social, and economic. But the CBAP leadership, during that time, chose to focus on growing big-sized churches. I felt CBAP neglected CJOL.”

Bishop Magbanua spoke the truth in love. I did not perceive any negative spirit or resentment. He shared his heart and mind as a wise older brother talking to responsible younger brothers. There was so much respect and transparency in that impromptu meeting.

Mark Sosmena was the first one to respond. He said, “Manong (Elder Brother) Fred, I speak as President of CBAP. Please forgive us for our neglect of you and CJOL in the past.” As his hand pointed to the church executives around him, he continued: “We’ll make sure that the relationship between CBAP and CJOL will be reviewed. We’ll also make sure that as we write CBAP history, we will be truthful and just in giving credit to whom credit is due.”

Bishop Noel Pantoja also shared his thoughts: “We are forming a CBAP historical committee who would write a more inclusive and transparent narrative of our journey as a Body of Christ. We will emphasize the contribution of the Filipino church-planters, including 50-lessons we have learned, in the last 50 years. We will also draft, in consultation with you and your leadership team at CJOL, a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) between CBAP and CJOL. We have to clarify our working relationship. By God’s grace, we will reflect and demonstrate the statement we just signed a few hours ago at the PCEC National Assembly.”

As a witness and a blogger of this amazing story of peace and reconciliation, my spirit worshipped the God of peace and of justice for allowing us to experience genuine shalom among some of the key leaders of Evangelical Christians in my beloved land!

And yes, my questions about peace-and-justice-vision translated into peace-and-justice-policy have been adequately answered.


Permanent link to this article:


Skip to comment form

    • Anne Benthien on 26.July.2011. at 09:20

    Hi Dann,

    Greetings from Milwaukee!

    The last time we met w/ your wife Joji, was in Bacolod…@ Luke Society’s Staff retreat ..1986 in the midst of EDSA revolution. You were our retreat speaker that time. Many of the biblical principles you taught greatly influenced my understanding and practice of holistic ministry. So glad to see many yrs later how God faithfully guided you in the Kingdom building ministry.

    This meeting reminds me of the passage in Psalms…”how good and pleasant it is when brothers live in unity…” truly a “heaven came down and glory filled your souls..” experienced. Just want to thank you for posting this Spirit-filled encounter with key leaders of CBAP & CJOL. Now I understand how CJOL grew..nice to see Nong Fred still strong in serving the Lord. I heard of CJOL from Ng Cynthia Capaque many yrs back.

    May God continue giving you double portion of His Spirit as you and Joji serve in His Kingdom building ministries.

    Anne & Steve Benthien

  1. Thank you very much, Anne! Your encouraging words are appreciated.

    Praise God for the fruits of those learning events together as the dark days of Martial Law under Ferdinand Marcos was coming to an end. Political powers will come and go, but God’s reign of justice and peace will continue to flow in and through the various segments of the People of God.

    As we face the current challenges here in the Philippines, we need a renewed commitment and a passionate move for social justice and peace — starting in the Church.

    • fermin manalo jr. on 04.July.2013. at 22:37

    coffee and peace makes life worth living.

    • jo bautista on 22.May.2014. at 01:11

    ang tagal na pala nito Ptr Dann!! medyo naluha nga ako remembering Bishop Fred and the journey now of Tita Aliw to continue CJOL…. sana natuloy talaga ang CBAP-CJOL MOA and the former is sustainable supporting the latter=)..God bless you in your journeys and JOurney.. Thank you for taking a long time to talk to me=)))

    may 22 2014=) b.

Comments have been disabled.


We are sent by Mennonite Church Canada Witness in partnership with our international community.